Behavioral Science Lab

Personality

The Personality Test Career Deep Read

Career Intelligence

Elevator Pitch AI Impact Map Personal Brand Strategy Ask Coached

The Lab

The Coached Model Coached Premium Coached Weekly Pricing
Mentor’s Corner

How I nearly chose the wrong career

About Rohan

Hey, I’m Rohan!

I write thoughts about life and career strategy a few times a month.

I run Coached, the behavioral science lab, and Resume Worded, the best software for job seekers.

A good place to start is our free 3‑minute, science-backed personality test.

When I was in college, all my friends wanted to be the same thing:

Management consultants.

It might sound boring, but everyone ambitious I knew dreamed of working at McKinsey, the most "prestigious" consulting firm at the time.

So guess what I wanted to do with my life?

Yup.

I wanted to be a management consultant at McKinsey too.

The funny / scary thing? I never once asked myself whether I'd enjoy it. I just wanted to get in. I did months of case prep, practice interviews, got through 5 interviews.

Then, I screwed up the final one and got rejected.

At the time, naïve 21-year-old Rohan was devastated. But it was the best thing that ever happened to me.

Because I ended up in tech, which I'd been treating as my backup plan, and it suited me about a hundred times better.

What's strange, looking back, is how certain I'd been. No one pressured me - my friends/family never told me "you should do consulting," nor was it a childhood dream. I just saw how highly people spoke of the job, and I started wanting it too. It felt like my own ambition.

This illustration couldn’t be loaded.Open the original image ↗

I was 21, so fine, I was young and impressionable. But I’m not sure age has much to do with it. I don’t think enough people, at any age, stop to ask where their goals came from.

We learn what to want

There’s a French thinker, René Girard, who had a theory about exactly this. He called it mimetic desire.

His theory: We don’t actually know what we want. So we work it out by watching the people around us. We see what they’re chasing, and we start chasing it too.

My favorite evidence for this is a study of lottery winners in the Netherlands. When someone won, their next-door neighbors started spending more on cars. The neighbors hadn't won anything! But someone else’s wants/desires made them want things too.

It’s also why every few years everyone suddenly wants the same thing. The Labubu toys went viral last year; it’s not like anyone’s ever woken up randomly and independently decided they needed a plush monkey hanging off their bag. They saw other people wanted one…so they did too.

Clearly, social media has compounded this problem. Every day, we’re exposed to thousands of people’s wants instead of a few dozen - and because of how our brains work, all those random wants end up as ours too. We suddenly start valuing random things like fame, clothes, Labubus, etc, even though we would have never wanted those things had we not consumed those pieces of content.

This illustration couldn’t be loaded.Open the original image ↗

A toy or random purchase is one thing. But the same influence can shape the work we pursue or what gives us fulfillment. Those deserve a little more scrutiny before we commit years to them.

Get clearer on what you actually want

I always recommend checking in on your goals. Because often we’re just on autopilot: once you start pursuing something, there’s plenty to keep you busy. You research, prepare, compete, get better. Making progress feels good.

It’s easy to get absorbed in all of that without giving much thought to whether you actually want what’s on the other end of it all.

Maybe you want to earn more. Maybe you want work you find interesting, or more say over how things are done. Maybe you want the recognition.

Then examine whether the thing you’re chasing would actually give you that. A promotion can come with more authority, but also move you away from the work you enjoy. It could still be a great move. You just want to understand what you’re choosing.

This is also what I mean by thinking from first principles: work through your reasons yourself. It’s good to be inspired by other people’s ambitions, but you should explain why it makes sense for you too.

Often, if you really want the thing, questioning and defending your goals will give you even more motivation to chase them.

This illustration couldn’t be loaded.Open the original image ↗

Side note: this is where knowing your own wiring helps. If you understand what actually gives you energy, how you like to work and what you tend to avoid, it's much easier to tell "I want this" from "I want this because people around me do."

Our research lab built a free tool for this. Give it your LinkedIn URL and in a few seconds it breaks down your career wiring: what you keep gravitating toward, what you avoid, the decisions you make without thinking about them.

Get your deep read

Who are you choosing to copy?

If Girard is right, we’re still going to be influenced by other people whether we like it or not. That’s how our brains work! So we might as well use that to our advantage and choose the people we’re “copying” intentionally.

Usually, we just absorb the ambitions of whoever happens to be around us. When your friends, colleagues and the people you follow all value similar things, it’s easy to assume those are the things worth pursuing.

Travel helps me notice this. Somewhere else, people are excited about completely different things. Something that feels incredibly important at home can barely matter somewhere else. Spend enough time in one environment and it’s easy to forget that its priorities are just one set of priorities.

So be deliberate about whose ambitions you keep exposing yourself to. Unfollow people whose updates keep making you chase things you’ve already decided aren’t important to you. Subscribe to people exploring directions you’re interested in. And where you have a choice, spend more time with people pursuing something beyond the usual goals in your circle.

We also pick up what feels possible from these people. Being around people who’ve changed careers later in life, for example, can make that option actually feel worth exploring when your usual circle treats it as unthinkable.

This illustration couldn’t be loaded.Open the original image ↗

I hope this helps you give a little more thought to what you’re working towards, and why. It’s good to be ambitious! But you’re allowed to be excited about a different future from the people around you. You don’t need everyone else to want it too.

Illustration of Rohan Mahtani
Written by Rohan Mahtani
From Coached Weekly, issue 373.

I also send these out by email.

This is Coached Weekly, my career notes where I share the tiny % of ideas that actually work in real careers. It takes 5 minutes to read, but could speed up your career by years. I write this myself (no AI). —Rohan Mahtani (LinkedIn)

Free. Unsubscribe any time.Read an issue first
Another essay5 min read

How to stop underselling yourself

In 2007, the Washington Post tried an experiment. They got Joshua Bell, one of the best violinists in the world, to put on jeans and a baseball cap and play anonymously in a DC metro station during morning rush hour.

Share this essay

From the essay

Original image ↗

Copy link